If Scotland could run all its affairs, have control of all of its money, imports, exports, take in all the tax from oil, whisky, food, tourism etc but still be part of the Union, what would everyone's thoughts be on that?

We are 15bn, and rising, in the hole each year.
They have never addressed how they would rectify that other than we are being told lies.
They know privately through the growth commission report but won’t share it publicly.